I am always on the hunt for the ultimate Italian comfort food, and I think I found it at Carmelina’s of Amityville on Long Island. This pizza joint is serving up a Tri-Color Chicken Parmesan Hero that is a total game-changer.
If you’re a fan of chicken parm and can’t decide between pesto, vodka, or traditional tomato sauce, this hero is the answer to all your prayers.
A Symphony of Flavors: Three Sauces, One Hero
What makes this hero so unique? It’s all in the preparation. Carmelina’s doesn’t just settle for one sauce; they layer three house-made favorites for a flavor profile that is absolutely elite:
-
The Foundation: A fresh, toasted hero roll is swiped with a generous amount of house-made basil pesto.
-
The Protein: They layer in juicy, thin-sliced chicken cutlets that are breaded and fried to golden-brown perfection.
-
The “Tri-Color”: This is where it gets interesting. The cutlets are drenched in a trio of sauces: creamy vodka sauce, traditional tomato sauce, and more of that vibrant basil pesto.
-
The Melt: A mountain of house-shredded mozzarella is piled on before the hero is baked until bubbly and golden.
The Finish: A Masterclass in Sauce
Once the hero is baked to gooey perfection, it gets another generous drizzle of all three sauces—tomato, vodka, and pesto—creating a beautiful, vibrant “tri-color” effect. It’s finished with a sprinkle of Parmesan and fresh parsley for the final touch.
When I ripped into this beast, the combination of flavors was unreal. The freshness of the pesto, the richness of the vodka sauce, and the classic tang of the tomato sauce all work together in perfect harmony. It’s the ultimate indulgence for any Italian food lover.
The Verdict
Carmelina’s has managed to take a beloved classic and elevate it into something truly special. Whether you’re sharing with a friend or taking on the challenge solo, this hero is worth every single bite.
-
Location: Carmelina’s of Amityville, Amityville, NY
-
The Feature: Tri-Color Chicken Parmesan Hero
-
Pro Tip: Don’t skip the extra sauce drizzle—it’s the secret to that perfectly balanced bite!
If you’re looking for a meal that is as beautiful as it is delicious, Long Island is calling your name.
What’s your go-to Italian sandwich? Do you prefer a classic chicken parm, or are you ready to try the tri-color experience? Let us know in the comments!
